AutoCAD vs Revit for Construction Projects: Quebec Comparison Guide 2025
- Marc Déziel
- Nov 15
- 4 min read
Choosing between AutoCAD and Revit for your construction projects? Your team has used AutoCAD for years, but you're hearing about BIM advantages with Revit?
The choice isn't simple. AutoCAD remains the reference tool for 2D drafting, but Revit transforms complex project management with intelligent 3D modeling. For Quebec institutional and commercial projects, the difference can mean 30% time savings and $15,000 savings per project.
In this guide, you'll discover each software's strengths and limits, when to use one or the other, and how to succeed in your transition.
AutoCAD: The 2D Technical Drawing Standard
What is AutoCAD?
AutoCAD is computer-aided design (CAD) software developed by Autodesk since 1982. It creates precise 2D plans and basic 3D models for architecture, engineering, and construction.
AutoCAD Strengths
Easy to learn: Shorter learning curve (2-4 weeks)
Total flexibility: Free drawing without structural constraints
Light and fast: Compact DWG files, performance on modest computers
Universal compatibility: DWG format recognized worldwide
Affordable pricing: License from $2,300 CAD/year
AutoCAD Limitations
No intelligent data: Lines are just lines, not walls with properties
Manual coordination: Changes must be repeated on each view (plan, section, elevation)
Manual quantities: Surface and material calculations by hand
Coordination errors: High risk of inconsistencies between views
No BIM: No integrated construction information
Revit: The Power of Intelligent 3D BIM
What is Revit?
Revit is a Building Information Modeling (BIM) platform developed by Autodesk. Every element (wall, door, window) contains intelligent data and updates automatically in all views.
Revit Strengths
Single centralized model: One change = automatic update everywhere
Intelligent data: Each element contains materials, costs, specifications
Automatic quantities: Real-time material schedules
3D coordination: Automatic conflict detection between disciplines
Institutional compliance: Required for Quebec government projects
Revit Limitations
Steep learning curve: 3-6 months to master basics
Hardware requirements: Powerful computer required (16-32 GB RAM)
Less flexible: BIM structure imposes modeling constraints
High price: License from $3,500 CAD/year
Large files: Complex projects can slow down the system
Comparison Table: AutoCAD vs Revit
Criteria | AutoCAD | Revit |
Type | 2D/basic 3D CAD | Intelligent 3D BIM |
Learning | 2-4 weeks | 3-6 months |
Price (CAD/year) | $2,300 | $3,500 |
Coordination | Manual | Automatic |
Quantities | Manual | Automatic |
Clash detection | No | Yes |
Institutional projects | Limited | Required |
Files | Light (DWG) | Heavy (RVT) |
Collaboration | Basic | Advanced (BIM 360) |
ROI projects >$100K | Medium | High |
When to Use AutoCAD?
Suitable Projects
Simple residential renovations: 2D plans sufficient
Construction details: Technical sections, assembly details
Landscape design: Site plans, irrigation
Small commercial projects: <$50,000 CAD, short deadlines
Quick modifications: Minor revisions to existing plans
Use Case Example
Project: Residential kitchen renovationBudget: $25,000 CADDeliverables: 2D plans, simple elevationsTime: 8-12 hoursOptimal tool: AutoCAD (fast, sufficient)
When to Use Revit?
Suitable Projects
Institutional projects: Schools, hospitals, CEGEPs (BIM mandatory)
Complex commercial buildings: >$100,000 CAD, multidisciplinary
Custom integrated furniture: Cabinets, modular libraries
Multidisciplinary coordination: Architecture + structure + mechanical
Repetitive projects: Reusable models (condos, social housing)
Use Case Example
Project: CEGEP modular libraryBudget: $250,000 CADDeliverables: BIM model, CNC shop drawings, quantitiesTime: 120 hours (vs 200h in AutoCAD)Optimal tool: Revit ($15,000 savings, zero fabrication errors)
ROI: Return on Investment Calculation
AutoCAD Costs (Project $100,000 CAD)
License: $2,300/year
Training: $1,000
Modeling time: 80h × $75/h = $6,000
Corrections/errors: $2,500
Total: $11,800
Revit Costs (Project $100,000 CAD)
License: $3,500/year
Training: $3,500
Modeling time: 50h × $90/h = $4,500
Corrections/errors: $500
Total: $12,000 (first year)
Revit Savings (Subsequent Projects)
Training amortized
Reusable families
Time reduced by 40%
Errors reduced by 85%
Positive ROI from 2nd institutional project
AutoCAD to Revit Transition: 5 Steps
Step 1: Needs Assessment
Analyze your project types (residential, commercial, institutional)
Identify projects requiring BIM
Calculate your 12-24 month ROI
Step 2: Targeted Training
Basic Revit training (40h)
Discipline specialization (architecture, structure, MEP)
Practical workshops on your real projects
Step 3: Pilot Projects
Start with a simple Revit project
Keep AutoCAD in parallel (progressive transition)
Document lessons learned
Step 4: Content Library
Create your standard Revit families
Adapt to Quebec standards (BNQ, CSA)
Build reusable project templates
Step 5: Standardization
Establish your internal BIM standards
Train entire team
Integrate Revit in all projects >$50,000
Can You Use Both?
Recommended Hybrid Approach
Yes, and it's often optimal! Many Quebec firms use:
Revit for complex institutional/commercial projects
AutoCAD for technical details, small renovations, site plans
Interoperability: Revit export → DWG for AutoCAD subcontractors
Typical Hybrid Workflow
Main modeling: Revit (architecture, structure)
Technical details: AutoCAD (complex assemblies)
Coordination: Revit (clash detection)
Final deliverables: PDF from Revit + DWG from AutoCAD
FAQ: AutoCAD vs Revit
Can AutoCAD do BIM?
No. AutoCAD is a 2D/3D drawing tool without intelligent data. For BIM, you need Revit or equivalent software (ArchiCAD, Tekla).
Should you abandon AutoCAD if adopting Revit?
No. Both are complementary. Keep AutoCAD for technical details and small projects where Revit would be oversized.
How long to master Revit?
Basics: 3-6 months. Advanced mastery: 12-18 months. Expert: 2-3 years of regular practice on varied projects.
Is Revit mandatory in Quebec?
Not legally, but de facto required for government and institutional projects (schools, hospitals, public infrastructure).
Can you open AutoCAD files in Revit?
Yes, Revit imports DWG. But they're static blocks, not intelligent BIM elements. You must remodel to benefit from BIM.
💡 Expert Insight
"The real question isn't AutoCAD OR Revit, but AutoCAD AND Revit. For Quebec institutional projects, Revit is essential: it reduces errors by 85% and accelerates approvals by 3 weeks. But AutoCAD remains unbeatable for quick technical details. The ideal team masters both and knows when to use each."— DEZIART
📚 Références et Ressources
DEZIART Supports Your Choice
Don't know which software to adopt for your projects? Want to migrate from AutoCAD to Revit without disrupting operations?
DEZIART offers:
✅ Free consultation: Needs analysis and recommendations✅ Custom training: AutoCAD, Revit, or both✅ Pilot projects: Support on your first Revit projects✅ Custom libraries: Revit families adapted to your standards✅ Bilingual technical support: Continuous post-training assistance
📧 Contact : info@deziart.com | 🌐 Web : www.deziart.com
Comments